For those that know me, I have been pretty supportive of the loans given to GM and Chrysler. I thought (think) that by keeping them alive the government is keeping hundreds of thousands of people working, if not millions. Yesterday both GM and Chrysler had to present plans to the government which detail how they are going to get out of the mess they are in by restructuring the company, restructuring their contracts, and restructuring their debt. What I believe we got was more of the same posturing, and not only that, requests from both companies for more money. Slowly the details on the plans have started to trickle out. GM will be closing down one way or the other Saab, Hummer, and Saturn brands. Chrysler stated that they will be working towards a working agreement with the Italian company Fiat, and discontinuing three more models (which they said they were going to do anyway). Both companies said they made progress on their deals with the UAW, but neither would provide evidence of such…other than talks are “on going”.
Without putting all my words together yet, I have come away quite disappointed. Neither speak to innovation, neither speak to how to survive in the future…both keep their hopes alive that they market will improve, just keep giving us money until then. My support is waning, and I have begun to believe that even if we are not saying that both GM and Chrysler are bankrupt, in reality that’s exactly what they are. GM has 35 billion in debt…21 billion of that was collected last year alone. GM is saying that they are coming out with new innovative cars that everyone wants, and we have the Chevy Volt which will take over the car business as we know it. I wish they explained who is going to be able to find a loan for a $40,000 battery pack, and how are you going to make money off of it when you probably can make about 1000 of them each year (at a loss mind you). Chrysler is saying that their fate falls with the acceptance of their alliance with Fiat. They say they have a bunch of new models coming out that will bring people back. They released a diagram which laid out their plans until 2015. Outside of a new large sedan, and a new Jeep Grand Cherokee, everything else will basically be Fiat based or a niche electric vehicle. Chrysler’s plan for a new mid size car (think Accord, and Camry), won’t be coming out for another 3 years. With the plan that Chrysler laid out, I cannot imagine how they can survive alone for the next 24-36 months without tax payer dollars.
So needless to say I am disappointed. I was expecting big things from GM and Chrysler today, instead I got a piece of bad steak and some steak sauce to make it easier to go down. Following this post, I’ll follow up with a few more examples how innovative these companies really are.